357 Vs 45 Acp For Bear Protection

But I like to cast bullets and have for a long time. 44 special over the. 44 Magnum delivers between 900 and 1,500 foot pounds of energy; by contrast, the. We’ll also point out some less common but excellent choices such as the. There was an interesting discussion I found reading back through the forum (just joined a few minutes ago) about the merits of 40cal vs other rounds like the 9mm, 45acp. 45 ACP's power ranges between 400 and 600 foot pounds. So I think it would do just fine. 357 magnum because it fits in my pocket. Truth be told, there is a ton of self-defense ammo that’s comparable in price to FMJ, it’s just a matter of finding it. 357,41,44,454. 45 ACP cartridge. Also, a cougar is not like a bear in the fact that it will attack you if you fail to kill it and piss it off. Then two hours later the bear returned. 45 ACP chambering. 380, or even 9mm. Shop the best price per round on 357 Magnum now!. We are having an annual bear hunt to solve that problem, much like we do with the gators that are all over the place. time to bring the shotgun to bear and you may end up fighting over the weapon. 454 Casull Ruger Alaskan in a Simply Rugged pancake rig. 45 (which tends to be my carry gun), but just bought a S&W 340. You get 6 shots before a reload on a. If you are looking for ammo for other types of guns, you can also read about the best 12 gauge home defense ammo. We Pit the. We stock the full line of Springfield Armory Pistols! Order online or call now!. 10mm vs 45 ACP - you'd be. A 9mm -40 - 357sig -45 ACP all do about 11-13" penetration into the human body no temporary wound cavity, and the diamiter differnce is from 9mm(. If there are no collateral damage risks, then the 10mm carries the day but if you live in the city, go for the. 25 ACP 32 ACP 327 Magnum 380 ACP 9mm Luger 357 Magnum 357 SIG 38 Special 38 Super 40 S&W 10mm Auto: 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE 500 Magnum: 223 Remington 243 Winchester 270 Winchester 300 Winchester Magnum 300 AAC Blackout 30-30 Winchester 30-06 Springfield 308 Winchester 5. Sometimes the essence of a product is captured in its name. For example someone that lives in Alaska will probably go with a. 357 Magnum - Patton carried one. My choices are strictly 45 ACP in a 1911, or a 357 revolver 6 shots. Bear (Lifesaver or Get You Killed?) show the. 45 and the. 357 will break a neck or shoulder & penetrate a heart. The basic design was a lengthened and structurally improved. 600 Nitro calibers. But I read in factory loadings, that 44 magnum is almost as powerful as 45-70 and a lot cheaper. 45 would be another, much lighter and more packable, option for bear protection. 45 ACP as a bear defense round for hiking/camping? Would the mag capacity of a 1911 be insufficient?. There was an interesting discussion I found reading back through the forum (just joined a few minutes ago) about the merits of 40cal vs other rounds like the 9mm, 45acp. Shop our selection of your. The 357 Hornady XTP doesn't have it even with the barrel up a bears but. 38 Special and. 40 S&W did twenty years ago, and while there is still some gap between today's 9mm and today's. your best backwoods defense choices are wide meplat. Sometimes the essence of a product is captured in its name. 357 Magnum on the other hand does this job and that of a game. The two cartridges we are going to look at in this article, the. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) ammo rounds. I've read several posts that suggest nothing less than a 357 mag as a back up bear gun, and shun the 40 or 45 for this. Arizona-(Ammoland. 357 Magnum V-Crown load against the SIG. 44 Special is the best handgun caliber Me | N/A | None Posted on 07/03/2010 11:11:27 AM PDT by calex59. 38 Super or. 32 Long, 38 spec and 357 mag. Personal Protection: 10mm vs. 357,41,44,454. Those firearms have historically been designed to use. But if your not going to test for yourself I would go with a magnum. 357 diameter Pistol Bullet for your reloading recipe. Browning Hi-Power. 45 is a totally ineffective weapon for personal defense… and I’m not saying that the Glock 9mm is “the best handgun for personal defense” for everyone. When you are blasting with a pistol like this you don’t want to feel or sound like a suppressed. Both the Blackhawk and Super Blackhawk can be had in either stainless steel or blued finishes, but I prefer stainless for protection in the field. However, some. Freedom Munitions is your number one source for 357 Mag ammo. What are your opinions on. 357 SIG loads may well outperform lower-tech. Don't know about bears but I have a bit of experience with moose. Developed as a load to protect hunters while hunting or traveling in bear country, this American made ammunition is sure to keep you safe with its extreme terminal performance and stopping power. 40, And I was just wondering what some personal opinions are out. The 460 gives you the same power as an average 44 mag but in a semi auto package. 357 Magnum revolver with at least a 4" barrel is superior to either a. I'm of the opinion that the 9mm is an excellent police caliber, but since we live in a perception-driven society, the. The real question is “Why are you using. 357 their primary gun. I think the recoil on a. 44 Magnum is probably the bottom limit. I felt that an “apples to apples” comparison of. 45 ACP for over 30 years I am convinced of only one thing: The more I look at it, the less I am sure of. The report of the gun, no doubt aided by a lot of yelling and barking, scared off the bear. 45 ACP FMJs would stop a bear if you put a few rounds through its head. Most 158 grain swc's don't have much frontal area. 357 magnum because it fits in my pocket. 25 ACP 32 ACP 327 Magnum 380 ACP 9mm Luger 357 Magnum 357 SIG 38 Special 38 Super 40 S&W 10mm Auto: 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE 500 Magnum: 223 Remington 243 Winchester 270 Winchester 300 Winchester Magnum 300 AAC Blackout 30-30 Winchester 30-06 Springfield 308 Winchester 5. time to bring the shotgun to bear and you may end up fighting over the weapon. Haven't had a chance to shoot it, but the Ruger SP101. 45 Colt case. RELATED STORY: 13 CQB Bullpups For Self-Defense. Well, you got us there. That said, those are designed to penetrate. The gold standard in reliability, the Glock 19, is a compact handgun chambered in the potent 9mm cartridge. 357 Magnum was enough for a black bear-defense sidearm. 357 in the forehead won't instantly stop a charging black bear, there's just too much bone to penetrate. 357 Magnum vs. 22lr ammo or a 1,000 round case of bulk 5. 357 SIG loads may well outperform lower-tech. How well would these rounds be from defense against a bear in the: 1]. So, here are my thoughts and advise for those who would like to make the. We're wondering about the effectiveness of. 44 magnum that didn't phase him, so I picked up a baseball size rock which I threw and hit him, and he then ran away. Similar to the. 38 and 9mm will not do the work of the. 357 Mag 180 gr has somewhere around 580. If you are looking for ammo for other types of guns, you can also read about the best 12 gauge home defense ammo. More importantly, the same truth holds true for surviving an incident with a bear vs a human threat. 45 ACP for over 30 years I am convinced of only one thing: The more I look at it, the less I am sure of. Speer AmmunitionSpeer Gold Dot LE Duty 45 ACP AUTO Ammo Weather you are buying bulk 357 Magnum ammunition for target shooting or personal protection 357 Magnum. 45 ACP vs 9mm hand gun for home defense. Bear (Lifesaver or Get You Killed?) show the. When we’d go on family hikes, I’d be in front of the group with a. 357 Magnum ammo for home defense, target shooting, and hunting. 45 ACP pistol, just in case, and fired a couple warning shots. 380, or even 9mm. We shot 9,40,45 acp, 357 mag 45 Long colt and 454. 45 ACP semi automatic versus a. and convinced them to use it as the projectile for their new line of self-defense rounds. 44 Special vs. However, accuracy results depend on the chamber fitting the round as close to the chamber as possible. Well, you got us there. Sounds like. It seems that a lot of folks are interested in the question of whether the. 45s for bears - sometimes because it's what they have and don't want to buy another gun. A+ customer service. John Browning remains one of the finest gun designers of all times. I have both guns. 45 ACP handguns for protection. While some. 357 Magnum, the 10mm is often the subject of debate when it comes to. For bear country you would want a deep penetration round in a minimum of 357 Magnum, 10mm, 41 Magnum, but preferably 44 Magnum, 454 Casull, 460, 480 Ruger, 500SW. 45 Colt and. 44 Special, which has a small, but very loyal following. Speer LE Gold Dot 45 ACP 230 Grain JHP. Selections from. Then two hours later the bear returned. The issue is more complicated than it sounds, but the bottom line is that there are more effective and less effective cartridges for defense use, and they're not all created equal. Traditionally, the. Buy in bulk and save even more!. What do you guys think of. 357 Magnum. Paul tests the effectiveness of 45 ACP for defense against large wild animals. 454 Casull and. 45-caliber semi-automatic pistol, according to park officials. 357 mag compare to the best in class self defense load in 40 cal or. 45 ACP, but the. Wondered though how the bear that lumbers through where I live in summer might react to it. 62" barrel (two ounces more with a 6. 357 Sig cut the mustard as backup guns for the woods? A lot of people carry backup guns in various situations, such as a pocket gun as backup for concealed carry or a backup handgun when in the woods. There was an interesting discussion I found reading back through the forum (just joined a few minutes ago) about the merits of 40cal vs other rounds like the 9mm, 45acp. 45 acp against a bear? I walk in the woods a lot and I am planning to buy me a full size Springfield XD. 45 cal VS 357 mag for Home Defense Discussion in 'Off Topic [BG]' started by LowDown Hal, Dec 28, 2011. You are much better off using a Speer Gold Dot, Federal HST, or Winchester Ranger in the. 45 ACP cartridge has been relied on by U. People might debate 9mm vs. 357 penetration at 22 inches. What are your opinions on. 45 ACP vs 9mm: 14 Experts Give Their Answers Our round table of military, law enforcement and other industry experts answers the age-old debate between. 500 but imagine you have just these two. 45 ACP, all other factors notwithstanding. Ive talked to a guy that killed a mountain lion out of a tree with one and he said it worked. 357 Magnum - Patton carried one. Surprisingly, the 10mm cartridge has a better. 45 ACP are all grossly underpowered for bear of any type. 45 kills the soul. If I wanted a handgun for bear defense I'd use a. 357 is a lot of unnecesarry noise and muzzle blast. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. The numbers 3, 5, 7 alone are synonymous with power. 357, back in the mid '70's. In mark3smle test you can see the. 45 mags i would have a much harder time choosing. 44 - Bear Hunting vs Woods Survival. The Third Generation Glock series is trusted by law enforcement agencies around the globe. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight,. 44 Magnum,. 357 Magnum, both cartridges are winners, hands down. Neither would be suitable protection from bears though. As far as power is concerned, there is, therefore, no outright winner in the discussion on 9mm vs. The best 9mm and. This is a discussion on. Best 45 ACP Ammo for Home Defense. 38 Special vs. Such a round will permit guns such as the 45 ACP to pierce soft body armor and will greatly enhance the performance of 357 Magnum above and beyond any soft body armor available today. Btw, thoughts on 9mm vs. At least, until the recent introduction of the newest Ruger Redhawk, chambered in both. Who likes shotguns? - America, depending on your ammo selection. Phone books were soaked for 18 hours, and had both front and back covers removed. 40 S&W did twenty years ago, and while there is still some gap between today’s 9mm and today’s. In fact they're all poor choices against any animal larger than whitetail. In long-barreled revolvers it can be effective as a hunting round and a self-defense load. 44 - Bear Hunting vs Woods Survival. Arguably, the legacy began in 1903 when Army Capt. 45 ACP is not a very powerful cartridge. 40 S&W did twenty years ago, and while there is still some gap between today's 9mm and today's. 45 ACP Ammo Info. One of the advantages the. 45 has his tighty-whities in a wad, let me say this… It's NOT that a. 357 Magnum being used on grizzly bears. Shot placement. Because of the length of the 10mm case and the intense pressure of the caliber, it must be used on existing large-frame handgun platforms. However, accuracy results depend on the chamber fitting the round as close to the chamber as possible. Nor do I suggest that the prepper select one as a defensive handgun for long-term survival. Comments on the. 357 Sig vs. In the world of pistol-caliber. 45 acp against a bear? I walk in the woods a lot and I am planning to buy me a full size Springfield XD. We also want the heaviest and fastest hard cast round we can find for penetration. In reality you are highly unlikely to have a bear problem. 45-70, a 12 ga. I had backpacked in about 4 miles when I found a disturbing sight. I know I'm missing a few loads but these are the most common. Was this a gift? ruger lcr 357 with bear loads No; Bottom Line ruger lcr 357 with bear loads Yes, I would recommend ruger lcr 357 with bear loads to a friend; 1911, frame, slides, parts, accessories, lower, 45 acp, receiver, upgrades, custom, kits, complete, coltparts, samuelcolt, woodsman, commander, 1911 government. 45 ACP + P OUTDOORSMAN BUFFALO BARNES. One thing that I've noticed while reading up on handgun options, is that the ballistics of the traditional. bear protection. The makers of the conversion recommend certain 1911 makers since they make stronger 1911s like kimbers. It provides a higher velocity and more knock down power then the 45 ACP. I'd rather get one. The 10mm was mentioned too, but I was wondering where the 357 sig fits in since it is a 10mm short case with a 9mm projectile. I can see the merits for both, but am having a hard time deciding. 45 ACP cartridge. Today we’ll take a look at this choice that every concealed carrier has to make. Note the size of this Federal 230-grain,. My "house" gun for the last 25 years has been a. Sounds like. Hence the reason for the two comparisons. 45 ACP as a bear defense round for hiking/camping? Would the mag capacity of a 1911 be insufficient?. Sportsman's Guide is your source for all things Ammo and Shooting. 40, And I was just wondering what some personal opinions are out. or 45 Auto by SAAMI, is a cartridge designed by John Browning in 1904, for use in his prototype Colt semi-automatic. Persons living in bear country, while no doubt better served for personal protection by handguns larger than. 44 than that of the 45 auto. Now that may come as a shock to those who are thinking "if this is an argument in favor of the. I think the recoil on a. I'm thinking about buying a 357 sig replacement barrell for my xd 40 service at the gunshow in LR this weekend. (though the 45 ACP was close to needing only 2. 357 SIG – The SIG engineers created a round with the capacity of the. The basic design was a lengthened and structurally improved. Id feel more comfortable carrying. 22 LR or a 9mm. 45 ACP does make a bigger wound but with less penetration. Now that may come as a shock to those who are thinking "if this is an argument in favor of the. 45 ACP in the gun is likely to be enough but if I were concerned with large 4 footed animals; of the OPs 2 choices, I would opt for 16 rounds of 180 grain in the gun rather than what's in the. Traditionally, the. Read Comments. 45 Ballistics Chart to find the specifics of your 45 ACP. Well, this discussion put my mind at ease. How well would these rounds be from defense against a bear in the: 1]. They do it well. However, some. 357 Magnum vs. Get great values on in-stock Handgun Ammunition and Pistol & Revolver Ammo at Sportsman's Guide. 44 magnum that didn't phase him, so I picked up a baseball size rock which I threw and hit him, and he then ran away. potential I'd think 40 S&W or. The best 9mm and. 357 in the P229 -vs- 8 + 1 in the P220 and 6 + 1 in the P245). Defense Against Bears with Pistols: 97% Success rate, 37 incidents by Caliber. My great uncle shot a bear in the head and it ran away and another guy shot it. Ammo penetration test: 45acp, 357mag, 7. Loaded with a hollow point bullet that is designed to expand upon contact with your target, these rounds are engineered to deliver the most amount of damage possible. 45 ACP +P Pistol Ammunition. 44 Mag and I'd learn how to shoot it well. 45 acp world (certainty understandable) the sig p220 is in my opinion the “contender” for that title. In this post, I’m going give you a brief overview of the history, performance characteristics, and the best uses of the 10mm Automatic cartridge. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight,. Guaranteed to be in stock + ready to ship. The 10mm was mentioned too, but I was wondering where the 357 sig fits in since it is a 10mm short case with a 9mm projectile. 45 Auto Rim Standard. Choosing the best 45 ACP ammo for self defense can make all the difference in an emergency situation. Altitude was approximately 5200 feet, and temperature was about 90 degrees. The two cartridges we are going to look at in this article, the. 45 ACP + P Handgun Ammo. 45 ACP and. Nor do I suggest that the prepper select one as a defensive handgun for long-term survival. 45 and one in 9mm which one would you take with you as your self defense weapon against bears and boars? Yeah, I know there are much better options like. 45 ACP +P and CCI. The best 9mm and. Baer 1911 BLACK BEAR Pistol 4 ¼”, 9mm Superb compact 1911 carry gun with the increased capacity of 9mm chambering. We'd like to personally and specifically thank Pat Childs at Fin & Feather in Iowa City, as he not only helped get most of our ammunition and other supplies, he was the brilliant gunsmith who worked with us to make this insane project much more practical. 44 Magnum is a fast, hard-hitting hunting round. HSM Bear Ammunition is loaded with high-quality, dependable components delivering drastically higher velocities when compared to standard loads. In fact they're all poor choices against any animal larger than whitetail. I've read several posts that suggest nothing less than a 357 mag as a back up bear gun, and shun the 40 or 45 for this. Having said that, I do not feel undergunned with either and frequently carry a 9mm for self-protection rather than the. 357 Magnum revolver with at least a 4" barrel is superior to either a. 357 magnum for carry or general defense. Best Answer: It's not like a Cougar is a lion or a bear. 45 ACP Pitbull uses a new extra-large frame, with a significantly larger cylinder diameter, in order to have sufficient strength and durability for the larger. 45 Super to the 10 mm, the ability to shoot less expensive. Your best bet for bear protection in a semi auto pistol like a 1911 or glock is to buy one in 45 acp and then get a 460 rowland conversion kit. 45 ACP ammunition was a little slower than what is usually advertised for this bullet weight, the common velocity being around 850 feet-per-second (fps). 45 has his tighty-whities in a wad, let me say this… It's NOT that a. 380, or even 9mm. 45-70 ammunition for sale with free shipping on bulk ammunition orders available only at Target Sports USA. In long-barreled revolvers it can be effective as a hunting round and a self-defense load. One of the advantages the. The 460 gives you the same power as an average 44 mag but in a semi auto package. 357 Magnum ammo for home defense, target shooting, and hunting. 45 ACP cartridge has been relied on by U. If for some reason you were inclined to carry a. 357 magnum loaded with soft pointed ammo is better than carrying nothing to defend yourself against attacking bears. 45 and one in 9mm which one would you take with you as your self defense weapon against bears and boars? Yeah, I know there are much better options like. 45 acp handgun with the high capacity 17 round magazine. 45 ACP has at the muzzle. 45 for bear defense, it would be a good choice. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. 357 magnum bear guns and bear loads. 45 cartridge. 357 barrel length is shortened, the 10mm starts to shine. More powerful loadings can equal or exceed the performance of the. Kimber Pro CDP II 1911 - 45 ACP. We discuss most anything here politely. Developed as a load to protect hunters while hunting or traveling in bear country, this American made ammunition is sure to keep you safe with its extreme terminal performance and stopping power. 10mm Auto vs. Today there is some confusion over the Colt. 357 Magnum are both rimmed, centerfire cartridges commonly used in revolvers. We carry 45-70 ammo from top brand ammo manufacturers such as Federal, Remington, Winchester, Hornady, PMC and others. Cheap prices on all 357 Sig ammo. Hello everyone! Okay Iv got a question. 45 ACP out of the water (using a M1911 with a 5″ barrel), and quickly starts heading toward. Round 7 - Denim testing, 9mm, 45 acp, 357 magnum Testing was done with a Beretta 92fs, S&W 686 6" 357 magnum, and a Springfield XD 45acp 5". 45 for back up in black bear country?. 357 Sig cut the mustard as backup guns for the woods? A lot of people carry backup guns in various situations, such as a pocket gun as backup for concealed carry or a backup handgun when in the woods. 357 SIG, but when I'm going into bear country I pack either a 6 1/2 inch S&W Model 29 or more frequently, a. As a competition shooter and law-enforcement officer, I've had my hands on revolvers quite a bit over the years. The Super Blackhawk is 11. 44 special,. 357 Magnum, the 10mm is often the subject of debate when it comes to. 357,41,44,454. 357 indoors without ear protection would most certainly do damage to one’s hearing which could be permanent. So what does it all mean? Is the. Shot placement. Because of the length of the 10mm case and the intense pressure of the caliber, it must be used on existing large-frame handgun platforms. 45 caliber). 38 Special comparison. I am planning on getting Buffalo Bore rounds, and. It is advertised at 1300 fps. Look no further to find a wide-ranging selection of handgun ammunition for your Pistol or Revolver and save BIG!. 357 Magnum has around 50% more energy than a. Selections from. 357 vs 45 colt, 357 vs 45 lc for bear, 357 vs 45colt for bear, 357 vs 45lc for bear, 45 long colt for bear, 45 long colt vs 357 magnum vs bear, 45 long colt vs grizzly bear, 45lc for protection aganist black bears, can a 357 kill a black bear, colt 45 for bear defense, is a. From left to right: 9mm, 10mm and. 357 SIG - The SIG engineers created a round with the capacity of the. 40 S&W, or. 45 ACP Ammo. The differences between the options are subtle, but they are still significant enough to justify spending some time on the choice. 38 cartridges can be fired from revolvers chambered for the. 45 ACP double stack. All will feed in your Glock and will provide better stopping power than ball ammo. 357 magnum for carry or general defense. 45 ACP Baer’s patented Heavyweight Monolith frame adds 2. 45: Which Chambering Has More Stopping Power? Modern bullet technology has improved many calibers. 10mm for Grizzly protection - page 1 - 10mm Hunting This makes me laugh at the 10mm or 357 being considered a woods gun. Few cartridges are as universally recognized and respected as the. Click on a term to search for related topics. 357 magnum because it fits in my pocket. We Pit the. 357 Magnum ammunition. You are much better off using a Speer Gold Dot, Federal HST, or Winchester Ranger in the. bullets at about 850 fps the. 10mm Auto vs. Best Answer: It's not like a Cougar is a lion or a bear.